Superseding Indictment Against Enrico Cifelli and Michelle Bocchieri for Tax Evasion
A federal grand jury in New Jersey returned a superseding indictment charging Enrico Cifelli and Michelle Bocchieri with conspiracy to evade payment of taxes and related offenses involving unpaid payroll taxes and personal income tax filings.
If the PDF does not display in your browser, download the original file.
Read with context. Charges and allegations do not establish guilt. A defendant is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court, and later filings may update this record.
About this document
At a glance
- The indictment describes Enrico Cifelli and Michelle Bocchieri as siblings who allegedly controlled several New Jersey businesses.
- The indictment details approximately $1.68 million in reported payroll tax liabilities from 2004-2015 that were allegedly never fully paid.
- The indictment describes multiple methods allegedly used to conceal Cifelli's ability to pay taxes.
- The indictment lists detailed financial transactions including: a $50,000 wire from Cifelli LLC for a home deposit on March 17, 2014; a $450,000 cashier's check from Cifelli LLC…
- The indictment alleges two instances of false tax filings.
For more details, keep reading below.
Defendants and Business Structure
The indictment describes Enrico Cifelli and Michelle Bocchieri as siblings who allegedly controlled several New Jersey businesses. According to the document, Bocchieri was listed as 99-100% owner of Cifelli LLC, a construction company, while Cifelli owned Cifelli Disposal Inc. (a waste disposal company) and LBAB LLC (a staffing company). The indictment alleges Cifelli exercised operational control over Cifelli LLC despite not being listed as an owner, and that he had no personal bank accounts, instead using business accounts and debit cards for personal expenses.
Supported by PDF pages 1, 2Alleged Payroll Tax Violations
The indictment details approximately $1.68 million in reported payroll tax liabilities from 2004-2015 that were allegedly never fully paid. For Cifelli Disposal (2004-2008), the document states only $513,464 of $1 million in reported taxes were paid. For LBAB (2009-2015), the indictment alleges only $64 was paid toward $671,442 in liabilities. The IRS reportedly assessed over $396,000 in penalties and interest against these unpaid taxes. The document states Cifelli was personally liable as a 'responsible person' under tax laws for the unpaid employee withholding portions.
Supported by PDF pages 2, 3, 5, 6Alleged Conspiracy Methods
The indictment describes multiple methods allegedly used to conceal Cifelli's ability to pay taxes. These include using Cifelli LLC funds for Cifelli's $1.35 million home purchase (including a $450,000 down payment), mortgage payments, and wedding expenses. The document states wedding gift checks made out to Cifelli were allegedly cashed rather than deposited. It also describes LBAB employees being paid in cash to allegedly avoid IRS levies, and Cifelli using business debit cards for personal expenses while maintaining no accounts in his own name.
Supported by PDF pages 8, 9, 10, 11, 12Specific Financial Transactions
The indictment lists detailed financial transactions including: a $50,000 wire from Cifelli LLC for a home deposit on March 17, 2014; a $450,000 cashier's check from Cifelli LLC for the home purchase on April 10, 2014; and $51,000 in bartered services for wedding expenses. It describes mortgage and utility payments from 2014-2020 allegedly made by Cifelli LLC for Cifelli's residence. The document also details a $350,000 personal loan to Cifelli that was allegedly repaid through Cifelli LLC funds and services.
Supported by PDF pages 12, 13, 14Alleged False Tax Filings
The indictment alleges two instances of false tax filings. First, it states Cifelli submitted a June 2016 Offer in Compromise that allegedly misrepresented his assets, spouse's income, and household finances. Second, it describes a May 2016 personal tax return that allegedly claimed a refund based on $9,624 in withheld taxes that were never paid to the IRS. The document states Cifelli knew these withholdings hadn't been paid when filing the return.
Supported by PDF pages 14, 18Criminal Charges
The superseding indictment contains seven counts: (1) conspiracy to defraud the IRS (18 U.S.C. § 371); (2) tax evasion (26 U.S.C. § 7201); (3-6) four counts of failure to pay over payroll taxes (26 U.S.C. § 7202) for quarters in 2015; and (7) filing a false tax return (26 U.S.C. § 7201). The document states these charges relate to conduct occurring between 2004-2020 in Monmouth and Middlesex Counties, New Jersey.
Supported by PDF pages 8, 15, 16, 17, 18Document record
- Document type
- Indictment
- Category
- Criminal
- Publication date
- 2022-04-28
- DOJ office
- USAO - New Jersey
- Case number
- 3:22-cr-00172-MAS
- Collected
- 2026-11-20
- Original filename
- cifellietal.supersedingindictment.pdf
Source & integrity
This copy is preserved from the linked source record. The fingerprint below lets you verify that the bytes have not changed.
b7d5c651c87b2c49a329bf42aa3956a09c1ee3efda01bd7a159a2c98d6fbc568Have documents of your own?
Upload them to ShareIt.onl to store them online, view them in your browser, and download them whenever you need.
ShareIt.onl is an independent index, not a government website. Documents are published here only after source and file-integrity review. Always use the linked justice.gov page for authoritative context and later corrections.