Order Denying Motions to Dismiss in United States v. New Mexico Supreme Court

A federal district court denied motions to dismiss a lawsuit alleging the New Mexico Supreme Court and Board of Bar Examiners violated the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act by refusing to recognize out-of-state law licenses for military spouses.

3unique views
0downloads
23pages
0.3 MBoriginal PDF
Document viewerorder_denying_motions_to_dismiss_-_united_states_v_new_mexico_supreme_court.pdf

If the PDF does not display in your browser, download the original file.

Read with context. This preserved document reflects its source and publication date. Check the linked source context page for corrections, replacements, or later developments.

About this document

At a glance

  • The Department of Justice alleges the New Mexico Supreme Court and Board of Bar Examiners violated the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act by denying attorney Liam Lees' license…
  • The New Mexico Supreme Court argued it is not a 'licensing authority' under the SCRA's definition because issuing licenses is not its sole primary purpose.
  • The court rejected defendants' narrow interpretation of 'licensing authority,' finding the New Mexico Supreme Court's constitutional duty to oversee judicial functions includes…
  • The court distinguished between the SCRA's allowance for background checks and New Mexico's broader character and fitness requirements.
  • The court found the government sufficiently alleged both a pattern of unlawful activity and a matter of significant public importance to establish standing.

For more details, keep reading below.

Alleged SCRA Violations Regarding Military Spouse Attorney

The Department of Justice alleges the New Mexico Supreme Court and Board of Bar Examiners violated the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act by denying attorney Liam Lees' license application despite his eligibility under federal law. Lees, a military spouse, was allegedly denied admission because he held an LL.M. degree rather than a J.D., which the state requires but the SCRA does not mandate for license transfers. The complaint describes multiple attempts by Lees to invoke SCRA protections, including submitting documentation showing his qualifications under federal law.

Supported by PDF pages 1, 2, 3

Defendants' Arguments for Dismissal

The New Mexico Supreme Court argued it is not a 'licensing authority' under the SCRA's definition because issuing licenses is not its sole primary purpose. The Board of Bar Examiners similarly claimed it lacks authority to issue licenses. Both defendants contended the SCRA preserves states' rights to conduct character and fitness evaluations beyond basic background checks. The New Mexico Supreme Court also challenged the government's statutory standing, arguing the complaint failed to show either a pattern of violations or a matter of significant public importance.

Supported by PDF pages 8, 9, 20

Court's Analysis of Licensing Authority Definition

The court rejected defendants' narrow interpretation of 'licensing authority,' finding the New Mexico Supreme Court's constitutional duty to oversee judicial functions includes regulating bar admissions. The opinion notes that reading the SCRA to exclude state supreme courts would make the law unenforceable for attorney licenses nationwide. Regarding the Board of Bar Examiners, the court found allegations sufficient to suggest it exercises authority over license issuance by rejecting applications and determining completeness.

Supported by PDF pages 9, 10, 11, 20, 21

Background Checks Versus Character and Fitness Evaluations

The court distinguished between the SCRA's allowance for background checks and New Mexico's broader character and fitness requirements. The opinion cites examples where 'background check' typically refers to criminal history checks rather than extensive evaluations of moral character, mental health, or professional conduct. The court noted the Board's own materials describe background checks as just one component of its character and fitness process.

Supported by PDF pages 14, 15, 16

Statutory Standing Under the SCRA

The court found the government sufficiently alleged both a pattern of unlawful activity and a matter of significant public importance to establish standing. The complaint describes the New Mexico Supreme Court's stated policy of non-compliance with SCRA requirements and its rejection of multiple applications from military spouses. The opinion notes the executive branch's role in identifying matters of public importance through its enforcement decisions.

Supported by PDF pages 18, 19

Procedural Outcome

The court denied both motions to dismiss, allowing the case to proceed. The ruling means the government's allegations that New Mexico's bar admission rules conflict with SCRA requirements for military families will be litigated further. The opinion does not make final determinations about the merits of the claims but finds them sufficiently pleaded to survive the dismissal stage.

Supported by PDF pages 1, 22
01

Document record

Document type
Court order
Category
Civil
Publication date
2026-11-19
DOJ office
Civil Rights Division
Case number
1:26-cv-01898-KWR-DLM
Collected
2026-11-21
Original filename
order_denying_motions_to_dismiss_-_united_states_v_new_mexico_supreme_court.pdf
02

Source & integrity

This copy is preserved from the linked source record. The fingerprint below lets you verify that the bytes have not changed.

SHA-256368b8d5a8c4edc86b0e8032da2bdcd8be323b76bcaf01167fd1386fa3931df8b
Open source PDF Open source context page

Have documents of your own?

Upload them to ShareIt.onl to store them online, view them in your browser, and download them whenever you need.

Upload your documents

ShareIt.onl is an independent index, not a government website. Documents are published here only after source and file-integrity review. Always use the linked justice.gov page for authoritative context and later corrections.